Kissing Jessica Stein is a comedy of sorts about "the surface level" and the insecurities of dating in the modern world. It questions how people think about sexuality and proposes that sexuality is painted in shades of grey, and is not strictly black and white.
I think that Helen and Jessica's relationship ultimately did not work out because of their difference in personality, not because of their gender. Jessica is neurotic and uptight, and her analysis of everything was bound to wear Helen thin. The casual viewer might assume that the relationship failed because of Jessica's ultimate "straightness", and maybe that was a factor, but if she was with the right person I think she'd be able to get over it.
Ultimately, I think love is about the person you are with. Love also extends outside of romantic relationships, which seems to be neglected by the romantic comedy genre. Friendships can be full of love, love that is just as deep and valuable as romantic love. Friendships can also be slightly erotic, as we discussed in class. Relationships would fare much better if they weren't so rigidly defined by society.
Reflection on Class
This class has introduced me to a new way of looking at love and desire, and I really enjoyed the readings, movies, and class discussions. I especially liked that we did not focus on the fluffy, easier aspects of love and desire- what would be the point of that? Disney pretty much has that covered, in my opinion. I welcome the opportunity to look at this subject with a critical and analytical lens, questioning subjectivity itself.
Some of the readings I will keep in my library, such as Madame Bovary (my favorite novel of the semester), and I plan on buying Simple Passion and Kristeva's writing, since both were really interesting and valuable to me.
Monday, December 3, 2012
12/4/12: The Readings
The New Yorker Article:
The premise of online dating itself has always interested me- wouldn't it just serve to make the dating process even more removed, the "other" even more unknown? The act of assigning the task of dating to a piece of software certainly says something about the state of human connection- people don't seem to be getting it right, so maybe computers can. As the article says, "In a fractured and bewildered landscape of fern bars, ladies' nights, Plato's Retreat, "The Bachelor", sexting, and the concept of the cougar, the Internet promised reconnection, profusion, and processing power." (3).
In some ways, online dating mocks dating in college, just as the article points out: "A college campus is a habitat of abundance and access, with a fluid and fairly ruthless vetting apparatus." People are constantly entering and exiting relationships, coming closer to understanding their needs and wants. However, with its seemingly infinite possibilities, online dating can feel cumbersome, and insecure. There's no way of really knowing who the person you are speaking to is, and although you can never fully know someone else, there's something disconcerting about that extra layer of removal.
I also found the section about the dating profile interesting- it is truly a "vehicle for projecting a curated and stylized version of oneself into the world." There is a certain amount of control you have over your image, which is usually determined by physical appearance. That power can remove us even farther from our perceptions of ourselves- you aren't really into reading, but if you "like" it on Facebook, you might catch someone's eye that you are fond of. There is no way of knowing the exact influence of social media presence on identity and in our relationships, but it is an influence. Facebook can attribute some of its success to this undying thirst to understand the other, and also to understand the self. If we list our every interest, post the best pictures, and think of the best comments, maybe we'll be closer to finding our true identity, to understanding ourselves and who we want to be.
"Serendipity and coincidence are the photosynthesis of romance, hinting at some kind of supernatural preordination, the sense that two people are made for each other." I believe in this, and think this is something online dating is missing- that you cannot determine your "perfect match" with fancy algorithms, and that we don't have a whole lot of control over when we'll get in a relationship, or how it will happen.
Kristeva
"A hymn to total giving to the other, such a love is also, and almost as explicitly, a hymn to the narcissistic power to which I may even sacrifice it, sacrifice myself."
I really enjoyed this article, and its focus on the narcissism of love- something touched upon by the last article but not discussed in detail. The "great sacrifice" of love is inherently narcissistic- it ties into the idea that you can "give" yourself to someone, that you are in fact in control, when you aren't. Also, as we have discussed in class, we tend to become attracted to people who we think possess qualities we want, and focus on these desirable traits.
Another stand out quote: "Perhaps the naivete of that debate conceals a metaphysical profundity- or at least a linguistic one. Beyond the revelation- yet another one- of the abyss separating the sexes, such questioning hints that love would, in any case, be solitary because incommunicable." I liken this to the "mirror stage" moment discussed earlier in the semester- realizing that the image in the mirror is an image, not our actual self. However, in the case of love, we are separated in many ways. We are separated sometimes by sex, always by this "metaphysical profundity", subjectivity, etc. Lovers don't experience their love in the same way, which makes love a unique, subjective experience.
This quote especially struck me: "Love is the time and space in which "I" assumes the right to be extraordinary. Sovereign yet not individual. Divisible, lost, annihilated; but also, and through imaginary fusion with the loved one, equal to the infinite space of super human psychism. Paranoid? I am, in love, at the zenith of subjectivity." I hadn't thought about the experience of love like that before, but I like thinking about it as the "zenith of subjectivity". Love does have a celestial, metaphysical quality that controls us, moves us, hurts us as it soothes us, and challenges us, something that nothing else can measure up to. I once heard that love is the closest humans can get to experiencing magic, and something about that is true to me.
The premise of online dating itself has always interested me- wouldn't it just serve to make the dating process even more removed, the "other" even more unknown? The act of assigning the task of dating to a piece of software certainly says something about the state of human connection- people don't seem to be getting it right, so maybe computers can. As the article says, "In a fractured and bewildered landscape of fern bars, ladies' nights, Plato's Retreat, "The Bachelor", sexting, and the concept of the cougar, the Internet promised reconnection, profusion, and processing power." (3).
In some ways, online dating mocks dating in college, just as the article points out: "A college campus is a habitat of abundance and access, with a fluid and fairly ruthless vetting apparatus." People are constantly entering and exiting relationships, coming closer to understanding their needs and wants. However, with its seemingly infinite possibilities, online dating can feel cumbersome, and insecure. There's no way of really knowing who the person you are speaking to is, and although you can never fully know someone else, there's something disconcerting about that extra layer of removal.
I also found the section about the dating profile interesting- it is truly a "vehicle for projecting a curated and stylized version of oneself into the world." There is a certain amount of control you have over your image, which is usually determined by physical appearance. That power can remove us even farther from our perceptions of ourselves- you aren't really into reading, but if you "like" it on Facebook, you might catch someone's eye that you are fond of. There is no way of knowing the exact influence of social media presence on identity and in our relationships, but it is an influence. Facebook can attribute some of its success to this undying thirst to understand the other, and also to understand the self. If we list our every interest, post the best pictures, and think of the best comments, maybe we'll be closer to finding our true identity, to understanding ourselves and who we want to be.
"Serendipity and coincidence are the photosynthesis of romance, hinting at some kind of supernatural preordination, the sense that two people are made for each other." I believe in this, and think this is something online dating is missing- that you cannot determine your "perfect match" with fancy algorithms, and that we don't have a whole lot of control over when we'll get in a relationship, or how it will happen.
Kristeva
"A hymn to total giving to the other, such a love is also, and almost as explicitly, a hymn to the narcissistic power to which I may even sacrifice it, sacrifice myself."
I really enjoyed this article, and its focus on the narcissism of love- something touched upon by the last article but not discussed in detail. The "great sacrifice" of love is inherently narcissistic- it ties into the idea that you can "give" yourself to someone, that you are in fact in control, when you aren't. Also, as we have discussed in class, we tend to become attracted to people who we think possess qualities we want, and focus on these desirable traits.
Another stand out quote: "Perhaps the naivete of that debate conceals a metaphysical profundity- or at least a linguistic one. Beyond the revelation- yet another one- of the abyss separating the sexes, such questioning hints that love would, in any case, be solitary because incommunicable." I liken this to the "mirror stage" moment discussed earlier in the semester- realizing that the image in the mirror is an image, not our actual self. However, in the case of love, we are separated in many ways. We are separated sometimes by sex, always by this "metaphysical profundity", subjectivity, etc. Lovers don't experience their love in the same way, which makes love a unique, subjective experience.
This quote especially struck me: "Love is the time and space in which "I" assumes the right to be extraordinary. Sovereign yet not individual. Divisible, lost, annihilated; but also, and through imaginary fusion with the loved one, equal to the infinite space of super human psychism. Paranoid? I am, in love, at the zenith of subjectivity." I hadn't thought about the experience of love like that before, but I like thinking about it as the "zenith of subjectivity". Love does have a celestial, metaphysical quality that controls us, moves us, hurts us as it soothes us, and challenges us, something that nothing else can measure up to. I once heard that love is the closest humans can get to experiencing magic, and something about that is true to me.
Monday, November 26, 2012
Simple Passion
As I read the excerpts from Annie Ernaux's Simple Passion, I was underlining like a madwoman. It felt like she was speaking directly to my personal experiences in an eloquent and realized way. I liked the way that Ernaux characterized her relationship with her desires- a masochistic/sadistic relationship of sorts, where the feeling you love and feel so attached to is also slowly killing everything else you once felt passion for.
Some stand out quotes, among many:
pg 4, "I behaved in an artificial manner. The only actions involving willpower, desire, and what I take to be human intelligence, were all related to this man."
- This seems to happen all the time when someone gets into a relationship with a new lover; all of a sudden, one passion succumbs all the others and every emotion gets redirected to this passion. Simple everyday conversations become directed to the object of desire and anything that doesn't relate, gets the cold shoulder of indifference.
Ernaux also discusses a yearning to establish credibility to her feelings through other people's experiences. If she heard about a relationship between a man and woman, she automatically made connections- as she said, "I felt they could teach me something about A and that they lent credibility to the things I wished to believe." It seems that we are constantly yearning to learn the inner workings of the "other", especially if the other is of the opposite sex. I know that the popular media tends to promote this; magazines like Glamour "unlocking" the secrets of the mysterious male- why doesn't he call? Why are his texts so cryptic? They use the promise of these answers as bait to reel in curious female minds, although no one can really provide them.
pg 27, "Sometimes I told myself that he might spend a whole day without even thinking about me. I imagined him getting up, drinking his coffee, talking and laughing, as if I didn't exist. Compared to my own obsession, such indifference filled me with wonder. How could this be?"
- This quote speaks to the desire to "know" someone; to understand their experience of the relationship and their perception of you. When you are so embedded in your own reality, you find it difficult to see how the other person could feel different, and how dare they! How dare they treat you with such indifference when you've devoted so much of yourself to the relationship! Again, it all comes down to your desires, your needs. It's not at all about the other person's reality- we only want to understand the other because it brings us closer to understanding how to get what we want.
pg 20, "I could experience only absence or presence."
- The strictly linear relationship we have with the other is daunting to think about, because the other can never be known. Our experience can only be one or the other- the other is physically there, the other is not there. Whether that person is there in every sense of the word, is unknown. As much as we'd like to uncover the perpetual mystery of the other, we can only get so close. The more you want it, and believe this absolute closeness is possible, the farther away it becomes. Each person has their own agenda, and if you are not a part of it, there's really nothing you can do, and it's even harder to understand why.
pg 33, second reading, "I experienced pleasure like a future pain."
- This is the quote that led to my comparison of the relationship to desire as a masochistic/sadistic one, because the pain of pleasure, and the pleasure of pain seem to be the same. When we indulge our desires, we know we're going to feel the pain of that moment ending immediately after we savor the pleasure of it, but we are okay with it. The pain of desire feeds into the pleasure of love, and we couldn't have pleasure without that pain.
pg 39, second reading, "My whole body ached. I would have liked to tear out the pain but it was everywhere. I longed for a burglar to come into my bedroom and kill me."
- The extreme pain of the realization of the loss of a lover is always likened to a life or death situation; a pain so severe we'd prefer absolute indifference in the form of death. In the moment, it feels like life will never go long, and you'll always be consumed with the fact that you aren't going to get what you want. Life's firm and unforgiving refusal to indulge such a strong desire delivers a hard blow, and it takes a while to recover. Of course, if you're a character in a story, most likely you are going to die to illustrate the severity of such feelings. Thinking about my own experiences with this, I remember going over each and every detail of the person with a fine tooth comb- although it wasn't really the person I was analyzing, but my perception of them and their qualities that I really wanted. I mourned the loss of someone who I thought matched my exact desires and needs in a partner, although in retrospect I know I was idealizing the situation.
pg. 59, second reading, "I had decided to learn his language. I kept, without washing it, a glass from which he had drunk."
- I really liked the way Ernaux worded this sentence- although there was an obvious language barrier between these two, there was a much more important barrier in place- the unique language of an individual's actions, words, and semantics. People may typically use standard languages to express themselves, but they use these languages in a particular way. Individual expression is just that, individual, and the individual is the only one who really understands what is being expressed. The difference between intention and perception is vast, and often is an obstacle in relationships. Why is it that we are constantly fighting to understand each other, decode the other's semantics, figure out what is really meant? It seems to always be so hard, because we all approach language with a specific culture, specific motives, needs, etc. Ernaux's attempt to get closer to A's language by keeping his glass, thinking that perhaps the spread of DNA on the glass's surface will reveal a long kept secret, is interesting and she's certainly not alone.
Some stand out quotes, among many:
pg 4, "I behaved in an artificial manner. The only actions involving willpower, desire, and what I take to be human intelligence, were all related to this man."
- This seems to happen all the time when someone gets into a relationship with a new lover; all of a sudden, one passion succumbs all the others and every emotion gets redirected to this passion. Simple everyday conversations become directed to the object of desire and anything that doesn't relate, gets the cold shoulder of indifference.
Ernaux also discusses a yearning to establish credibility to her feelings through other people's experiences. If she heard about a relationship between a man and woman, she automatically made connections- as she said, "I felt they could teach me something about A and that they lent credibility to the things I wished to believe." It seems that we are constantly yearning to learn the inner workings of the "other", especially if the other is of the opposite sex. I know that the popular media tends to promote this; magazines like Glamour "unlocking" the secrets of the mysterious male- why doesn't he call? Why are his texts so cryptic? They use the promise of these answers as bait to reel in curious female minds, although no one can really provide them.
pg 27, "Sometimes I told myself that he might spend a whole day without even thinking about me. I imagined him getting up, drinking his coffee, talking and laughing, as if I didn't exist. Compared to my own obsession, such indifference filled me with wonder. How could this be?"
- This quote speaks to the desire to "know" someone; to understand their experience of the relationship and their perception of you. When you are so embedded in your own reality, you find it difficult to see how the other person could feel different, and how dare they! How dare they treat you with such indifference when you've devoted so much of yourself to the relationship! Again, it all comes down to your desires, your needs. It's not at all about the other person's reality- we only want to understand the other because it brings us closer to understanding how to get what we want.
pg 20, "I could experience only absence or presence."
- The strictly linear relationship we have with the other is daunting to think about, because the other can never be known. Our experience can only be one or the other- the other is physically there, the other is not there. Whether that person is there in every sense of the word, is unknown. As much as we'd like to uncover the perpetual mystery of the other, we can only get so close. The more you want it, and believe this absolute closeness is possible, the farther away it becomes. Each person has their own agenda, and if you are not a part of it, there's really nothing you can do, and it's even harder to understand why.
pg 33, second reading, "I experienced pleasure like a future pain."
- This is the quote that led to my comparison of the relationship to desire as a masochistic/sadistic one, because the pain of pleasure, and the pleasure of pain seem to be the same. When we indulge our desires, we know we're going to feel the pain of that moment ending immediately after we savor the pleasure of it, but we are okay with it. The pain of desire feeds into the pleasure of love, and we couldn't have pleasure without that pain.
pg 39, second reading, "My whole body ached. I would have liked to tear out the pain but it was everywhere. I longed for a burglar to come into my bedroom and kill me."
- The extreme pain of the realization of the loss of a lover is always likened to a life or death situation; a pain so severe we'd prefer absolute indifference in the form of death. In the moment, it feels like life will never go long, and you'll always be consumed with the fact that you aren't going to get what you want. Life's firm and unforgiving refusal to indulge such a strong desire delivers a hard blow, and it takes a while to recover. Of course, if you're a character in a story, most likely you are going to die to illustrate the severity of such feelings. Thinking about my own experiences with this, I remember going over each and every detail of the person with a fine tooth comb- although it wasn't really the person I was analyzing, but my perception of them and their qualities that I really wanted. I mourned the loss of someone who I thought matched my exact desires and needs in a partner, although in retrospect I know I was idealizing the situation.
pg. 59, second reading, "I had decided to learn his language. I kept, without washing it, a glass from which he had drunk."
- I really liked the way Ernaux worded this sentence- although there was an obvious language barrier between these two, there was a much more important barrier in place- the unique language of an individual's actions, words, and semantics. People may typically use standard languages to express themselves, but they use these languages in a particular way. Individual expression is just that, individual, and the individual is the only one who really understands what is being expressed. The difference between intention and perception is vast, and often is an obstacle in relationships. Why is it that we are constantly fighting to understand each other, decode the other's semantics, figure out what is really meant? It seems to always be so hard, because we all approach language with a specific culture, specific motives, needs, etc. Ernaux's attempt to get closer to A's language by keeping his glass, thinking that perhaps the spread of DNA on the glass's surface will reveal a long kept secret, is interesting and she's certainly not alone.
Monday, November 19, 2012
My Love Song: One Marathon by Reverie Sound Revue
I chose "One Marathon" by Reverie Sound Revue; a song by a very indie Canadian band. These are the lyrics:
I see you, carry the course
Some girl up and left again
And the sun seems to follow through
Oh, On a promise to follow you
Maybe the climb will in time
Remind you as you're always
Seeking me on harmony of rhyme
In time, as I wait, as time unwinds
As I dive over the finish line
As I dive over the finish line
I see you, call his name, Bliss,
I can't explain the whys of your wishing
Then you call me places
And you leave me aging
While I send my senses
I play by patience
But I know you know I
I must swear you hear my say
"No, our misses are not a plan"
So I miss you
And I run through
Through you
As I dive over the finish line
As I dive over the finish line
As I dive over the finish line
This song incorporates some natural imagery- the sun, "the climb"- to describe a person's love for someone who is not in their physical environment. This person is willing to wait for this love, withstand any test it might face, which is something I can relate to. The title, One Marathon, refers to the idea of a race against time, and that eventually love can "dive over the finish line," become a reality. Time is a temporary separation, and if you believe in your feelings, you just need to have patience. The line "I can't explain the whys of your wishing" especially resonates with me, because so much of what we feel is inexplicable. Sometimes you cannot explain what happens in your life, why you love someone despite any logical deterrences, or why you hold onto hope for a future with someone who is not physically available. The feeling of love itself is hard to explain or justify.
I think that love and desire for someone can continue on indefinitely, despite the circumstances of the relationship. You will miss that person, and maintain hope that you will be reunited someday- and it is not foolish to have that hope. Life is unpredictable, and it is not impossible for two lives to come back together after some time apart. Sometimes, that time was necessary, and the relationship is better for it. I think it is important to know how to miss someone- you better understand your feelings and appreciate that person in a way you hadn't before. How do you know if you really love someone if that person is around all the time, and the relationship never had to undergo any tests?
This song is inherently hopeful, just as I am about love. I believe everyone has a chance to experience a good relationship, one built on a real connection that has undergone some kind of test and has pushed through the hard times. Love is not instant; it takes time. Sometimes, it takes some distance too.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tfqVHYhIp9M
I see you, carry the course
Some girl up and left again
And the sun seems to follow through
Oh, On a promise to follow you
Maybe the climb will in time
Remind you as you're always
Seeking me on harmony of rhyme
In time, as I wait, as time unwinds
As I dive over the finish line
As I dive over the finish line
I see you, call his name, Bliss,
I can't explain the whys of your wishing
Then you call me places
And you leave me aging
While I send my senses
I play by patience
But I know you know I
I must swear you hear my say
"No, our misses are not a plan"
So I miss you
And I run through
Through you
As I dive over the finish line
As I dive over the finish line
As I dive over the finish line
This song incorporates some natural imagery- the sun, "the climb"- to describe a person's love for someone who is not in their physical environment. This person is willing to wait for this love, withstand any test it might face, which is something I can relate to. The title, One Marathon, refers to the idea of a race against time, and that eventually love can "dive over the finish line," become a reality. Time is a temporary separation, and if you believe in your feelings, you just need to have patience. The line "I can't explain the whys of your wishing" especially resonates with me, because so much of what we feel is inexplicable. Sometimes you cannot explain what happens in your life, why you love someone despite any logical deterrences, or why you hold onto hope for a future with someone who is not physically available. The feeling of love itself is hard to explain or justify.
I think that love and desire for someone can continue on indefinitely, despite the circumstances of the relationship. You will miss that person, and maintain hope that you will be reunited someday- and it is not foolish to have that hope. Life is unpredictable, and it is not impossible for two lives to come back together after some time apart. Sometimes, that time was necessary, and the relationship is better for it. I think it is important to know how to miss someone- you better understand your feelings and appreciate that person in a way you hadn't before. How do you know if you really love someone if that person is around all the time, and the relationship never had to undergo any tests?
This song is inherently hopeful, just as I am about love. I believe everyone has a chance to experience a good relationship, one built on a real connection that has undergone some kind of test and has pushed through the hard times. Love is not instant; it takes time. Sometimes, it takes some distance too.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tfqVHYhIp9M
Monday, November 12, 2012
The Bad Girl: Part Two
"I spent forty-eight hours in a somnambulistic state, alternating between spasms of lucidity and a mental fog that lifted occasionally so I could give myself over to a masochistic session of insults: imbecile, cretin, you deserve everything that happens to you, has happened to you, will happen to you."
- page 156
This sentence stuck out to me as I began to read the remainder of this novel. Desiring someone who does not give any kind of feedback to this desire puts a person in an odd mental space; is there hope? Is there no chance that this person will feel the same as I do?
Sometimes it feels like you have the answer, and then something happens to ruin the picture crafted so carefully in your mind. There's really no way to explain it; is it fate? Is there a reason why the smoldering desire within you persists through unlikely circumstances?
The way Ricardo and "The bad girl" seem to reunite at pivotal moments in their lives certainly suggests that fate is involved in their chance meetings. Ricardo's sexual obsession seems to be the most important part of his simple life, and the only part of him still tied to his Peruvian roots. His obsession is also the only connection the bad girl has to her roots; their relationship is like "home" to each other, a place to know and belong to, especially when the bad girl gets sick.
This novel had a strange effect on me; even at the end, I knew so little about Ricardo and the bad girl outside of their love for one another (if it could be called love) and desired to know more about them as characters. Although we learn a little bit about the bad girl's traumatic past, I still wanted to understand her. Obviously, the intention of the author was not to develop fully human characters as much as representations of the effects of love- when the desired is always changing, but the desirer is always wanting, no matter what changes occur.
The last paragraph of the novel was particularly interesting, when the bad girl tells Ricardo that "at least you have something to write about." I find this humorous- because most great works of art are inspired by love, or a study in an experience of love, but also because Vargas Llosa was so inspired by Flaubert, inspired enough to write a novel. Sometimes the best works of art come from a bad experience- I know that I always want to turn something particularly difficult that has happened in my life into something creative and meaningful. I am much more connected to what I create and I'm also healing through the process of creation- something that might have happened to Vargas Llosa. He is clearly making comments about the physical home, ties to one's heritage, and the emotional home, and how the answers are not always set in stone.
Life is always subject to change, and nothing about love is ever entirely clear or logical. There may be no logical reason for Ricardo to hold onto his feelings for the bad girl, but nothing was going to stop him, and nothing could possibly explain why.
Tuesday, November 6, 2012
I Am Love
Pleasure.
This film, put simply, is about the human desire for pleasure, any kind of pleasure. Pleasure that is felt deeply and savored like a fine piece of shrimp.
The cinematography of this film is a pleasure for the audience to watch, with the beautiful locale and elegant shots. It also reflects this need for desire, such as when Emma is first tasting the shrimp Antonio cooked.
The love affair between Emma and Antonio, and the imagery associated with it (such as when they first have sex with one another) symbolizes the desire within human nature to experience pleasure by having sex, and feeling with all the senses. Just like Emma Bovary, Emma wants to experience pleasure, the realization of her desires.
Emma's desires also extend outside of her position in society- she is a married woman, and Antonio is not exactly a member of her class. Her affair with Antonio is rebellious, and it makes a statement, similar to the one Emma Bovary's character made. Emma wanted what she wanted and she had the power to get it, and the audacity to go against society's rules.
It is interesting to see these characters so fully going after what they want and simply enjoying themselves in the pleasures of life.
This film, put simply, is about the human desire for pleasure, any kind of pleasure. Pleasure that is felt deeply and savored like a fine piece of shrimp.
The cinematography of this film is a pleasure for the audience to watch, with the beautiful locale and elegant shots. It also reflects this need for desire, such as when Emma is first tasting the shrimp Antonio cooked.
The love affair between Emma and Antonio, and the imagery associated with it (such as when they first have sex with one another) symbolizes the desire within human nature to experience pleasure by having sex, and feeling with all the senses. Just like Emma Bovary, Emma wants to experience pleasure, the realization of her desires.
Emma's desires also extend outside of her position in society- she is a married woman, and Antonio is not exactly a member of her class. Her affair with Antonio is rebellious, and it makes a statement, similar to the one Emma Bovary's character made. Emma wanted what she wanted and she had the power to get it, and the audacity to go against society's rules.
It is interesting to see these characters so fully going after what they want and simply enjoying themselves in the pleasures of life.
Monday, November 5, 2012
The Bad Girl, Part One: Thoughts
Whilst reading the beginning of this novel, I got the sense that Vargas Llosa was deeply inspired by Madame Bovary, and the controversy of a female character who is allowed to function as a man would within the realm of the novel. (I also noted that Flaubert gets a shout out on page 45!) I read Ricardo as a less boring Charles Bovary with traits of Emma's; a man who delights in simplicity like Charles (although Charles was more just simple, and did not "desire" simplicity) and desires a romantic, ideal love much like Emma. Ricardo also had an unstable childhood and looked to novels to escape, desiring an adventure to Paris. He desires Lily just as Emma desired any man she was with in the novel; she seemingly represents everything he wants in a woman.
"With her model's looks, her dark mischievous eyes, and her small mouth with full lips, Lily was the incarnation of coquettishness." - page 6.
The quote above makes Lily's function in the novel obvious, the language even says that she is "a flirt". Coquettishness is a french saying for flirt, which is meaningful considering Ricardo's fascination with Paris. Anyway, a flirt is the ultimate object of desire, as they never follow through on what their behavior suggests. Their presence is as fleeting as the promise of their touch or their words. This novel reminds me of That Obscure Object of Desire for this reason, and because Lily is not the same person throughout the novel. It does not matter so much who she is as what she represents; she is the object of desire. No matter where Ricardo is in life, he will always desire her, no matter who she is.
The shape-shifting of Lily's character throughout the novel is similar to Emma's interactions with the men in Madame Bovary. It didn't matter who those men were; Emma wanted what she wanted, and she was going to search until she found what she was looking for. Lily could be ten different people and Ricardo would still desire her just the same. An example of this is when Ricardo first came across Lily in Paris, now Mrs. Richardson. "In love with me without knowing me? Do you mean that for ten years you've been hoping that one day a girl like me would turn up in your life?" (pg. 23). Ricardo truly believes this is the same person he was "in love" with, and will not stop desiring her, although he never really knew "Lily."
Lily's infidelity reminded me of Emma, although their infidelity has different purposes. Emma had affairs because she was searching for an idealized love, much like Ricardo. She was obsessed with this image and determined to see it realized. Lily was adulterous because she is the object of desire, and an object of desire cannot be contained. She is a "bad girl", a girl with no ties to monogamy and no concept of loyalty. She desires being the "object of desire" just as much as Ricardo desires her. Her identity is malleable because it needs to be if she is going to be the elusive figure that is lusted after.
The language that Vargas Llosa uses is very telling of the novel's overall meaning; sentences such as "she breathed in the warmth of day and let herself be penetrated and adored by the light that filtered through the tops of the weeping willows," (pg. 53) compares the light of day to one of Lily's male admirers, something that desires and "adores" her presence. The novel is beautifully written and the language makes desiring Lily sound appealing to the reader. It was hard to choose quotes to use in this post because there are a million that say something profound and interesting.
Lily describes Ricardo very well when she says, "You're satisfied with what you have, aren't you? But it isn't anything, good boy. I'll never be satisfied with what I have. I'll always want more." (pg 57). Lily is like Emma in this way; she is constantly desiring to be desired, just as Ricardo desires her and her only. When Ricardo is with Lily, he is entirely satisfied, but desire cannot be entirely fulfilled, so he cannot have her.
Although Lily is primarily an object of desire, she has a lot in common with Emma. She is somehow always burdened by society, sticking true to what Emma had said in Madame Bovary about men being free and women being burdened. She is captive to her desires too, and her relentless appetite to break free imprisons her.
The first half of the book chronicles Ricardo's obsession and Lily's indifference, and how it might look for Ricardo to see his obsession a bit more realistically. Chapter Four, and what happens when Lily has sex with him for her "lord", brings reality into Ricardo's world, to a place where he questions his devotion and wonders why he has been so subservient to it for so long.
"With her model's looks, her dark mischievous eyes, and her small mouth with full lips, Lily was the incarnation of coquettishness." - page 6.
The quote above makes Lily's function in the novel obvious, the language even says that she is "a flirt". Coquettishness is a french saying for flirt, which is meaningful considering Ricardo's fascination with Paris. Anyway, a flirt is the ultimate object of desire, as they never follow through on what their behavior suggests. Their presence is as fleeting as the promise of their touch or their words. This novel reminds me of That Obscure Object of Desire for this reason, and because Lily is not the same person throughout the novel. It does not matter so much who she is as what she represents; she is the object of desire. No matter where Ricardo is in life, he will always desire her, no matter who she is.
The shape-shifting of Lily's character throughout the novel is similar to Emma's interactions with the men in Madame Bovary. It didn't matter who those men were; Emma wanted what she wanted, and she was going to search until she found what she was looking for. Lily could be ten different people and Ricardo would still desire her just the same. An example of this is when Ricardo first came across Lily in Paris, now Mrs. Richardson. "In love with me without knowing me? Do you mean that for ten years you've been hoping that one day a girl like me would turn up in your life?" (pg. 23). Ricardo truly believes this is the same person he was "in love" with, and will not stop desiring her, although he never really knew "Lily."
Lily's infidelity reminded me of Emma, although their infidelity has different purposes. Emma had affairs because she was searching for an idealized love, much like Ricardo. She was obsessed with this image and determined to see it realized. Lily was adulterous because she is the object of desire, and an object of desire cannot be contained. She is a "bad girl", a girl with no ties to monogamy and no concept of loyalty. She desires being the "object of desire" just as much as Ricardo desires her. Her identity is malleable because it needs to be if she is going to be the elusive figure that is lusted after.
The language that Vargas Llosa uses is very telling of the novel's overall meaning; sentences such as "she breathed in the warmth of day and let herself be penetrated and adored by the light that filtered through the tops of the weeping willows," (pg. 53) compares the light of day to one of Lily's male admirers, something that desires and "adores" her presence. The novel is beautifully written and the language makes desiring Lily sound appealing to the reader. It was hard to choose quotes to use in this post because there are a million that say something profound and interesting.
Lily describes Ricardo very well when she says, "You're satisfied with what you have, aren't you? But it isn't anything, good boy. I'll never be satisfied with what I have. I'll always want more." (pg 57). Lily is like Emma in this way; she is constantly desiring to be desired, just as Ricardo desires her and her only. When Ricardo is with Lily, he is entirely satisfied, but desire cannot be entirely fulfilled, so he cannot have her.
Although Lily is primarily an object of desire, she has a lot in common with Emma. She is somehow always burdened by society, sticking true to what Emma had said in Madame Bovary about men being free and women being burdened. She is captive to her desires too, and her relentless appetite to break free imprisons her.
The first half of the book chronicles Ricardo's obsession and Lily's indifference, and how it might look for Ricardo to see his obsession a bit more realistically. Chapter Four, and what happens when Lily has sex with him for her "lord", brings reality into Ricardo's world, to a place where he questions his devotion and wonders why he has been so subservient to it for so long.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)